Five Minute Journals vs. Standard Journaling: Which Is Better for You?

This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

You’ve heard you should journal.

Maybe your therapist suggested it. Maybe you read about it on a productivity blog or heard a successful CEO swear by it on a podcast. They all say it’s life-changing. It can clear your mind, boost your happiness, and help you reach your goals.

So you buy a beautiful, new, blank notebook. You open it to the first page.

And… you freeze.

The blank page stares back at you, waiting. What are you supposed to write? “Dear Diary”? Should you talk about the weather? What you ate for lunch? That weird thing your boss said? It feels awkward, and you’re not even sure what the point is. After five minutes of anxious silence, you close the book and put it on your shelf, where it gathers dust.

This is “blank page paralysis,” and it’s the #1 reason most people fail to build a journaling habit.

On the other flip side, maybe you tried a “guided” journal, like the popular Five Minute Journal. It’s simple, with little boxes to fill in. “I am grateful for…” “What would make today great?” At first, it’s a relief. It’s easy! It only takes a few minutes.

But after a few weeks, it starts to feel… repetitive. Like a chore. And when you have a really bad day, the little box asking for “3 Amazing Things That Happened” feels almost insulting. There’s no space to vent, to explore the messy, complicated why behind your feelings.

This is the core battle of modern journaling: Structure vs. Freedom.

Do you need a guided system that’s fast and positive, or do you need a blank canvas to explore your deepest thoughts?

Welcome to the definitive guide on the subject. We’re going to explore every corner of this debate. We’ll look at the deep psychology behind why each method works, for whom it works, and where it falls short. By the time you’re done reading, you won’t just know the difference between these two practices. You’ll know yourself better, and you’ll know exactly which tool is the right one for you.

What Are We Even Talking About? The True Goal of Journaling

Before we compare two models, let’s zoom out. What is journaling?

Forget the stereotype of a teenager writing “Dear Diary” and hiding a key.

At its core, journaling is simply the act of thinking on paper.

It’s a tool for self-reflection. It’s a way to take the messy, chaotic, and invisible cloud of thoughts, feelings, and worries inside your head and translate them into solid, linear, and visible words on a page. And in that simple act of translation, something magic happens.

• You get clarity. Thoughts stop looping. You see patterns.
• You process emotions. Giving a feeling a name and a story takes away its power.
• You solve problems. Writing about a problem forces your brain to structure it, often revealing the solution.
• You become more mindful. You stop sleepwalking through your life and start paying attention to it.

Both the Five Minute Journal and standard journaling are just different systems designed to help you do this. They are like a structured workout class versus a walk in the woods. Both are “exercise,” but they serve very different purposes and suit very different people.

Let’s break them down, piece by piece.

Deep Dive: The Five Minute Journal (The Power of Structure)

The Five Minute Journal (or “5MJ”) is the most popular example of a “guided journal.” It’s a physical book created by Alex Ikonn and UJ Ramdas, and it’s built on the science of positive psychology.

Its entire philosophy is built on a simple idea: Your day will follow your mind. If you start your day by focusing on the good and setting positive intentions, you are priming your brain to have a better day.

It’s designed to be the lowest-friction, highest-reward habit you can build.

The Exact Format: How It Works

The 5MJ is split into two tiny sections: a morning routine (about 3-4 minutes) and an evening routine (about 1-2 minutes).

In the Morning, you fill out 5 prompts:

• A daily quote: The journal provides this for you.
• “I am grateful for…” (You list 3 things.)
• “What would make today great?” (You list 3 things.)
• “Daily affirmation. I am…” (You write 1 affirmation.)

In the Evening, you fill out 2 prompts:

• “3 amazing things that happened today…”
• “How could I have made today even better?”

That’s it. It’s a simple, repeatable formula.

The Psychology: Why This Simple Formula Is So Powerful

This format isn’t random. Each prompt is a precision tool designed to rewire your brain.

1. The Gratitude Prompts (“I am grateful for…”)

This is the core of the journal. It’s not just about “being nice.” It’s about actively training your brain’s focus.

Think of your brain like a search engine. Whatever you type in, it will find. If you wake up and think, “Today is going to be awful,” your brain will search all day for evidence to prove you right. This is sometimes called the Reticular Activating System (RAS)—a part of your brain that filters information and only shows you what it thinks is “important.”

When you force yourself to list 3 specific things you’re grateful for (e.g., “the good coffee I’m drinking,” “the sun coming through the window,” “a supportive text from my friend”), you are giving your brain a new search command: “Find the good.”

Suddenly, your brain starts filtering your reality differently. You notice the good things more. It’s a workout for your perspective.

2. The Intention Prompts (“What would make today great?”)

This prompt isn’t a to-do list. It’s an intention list.

A to-do list might say “Finish the report.” An intention says, “Focus without distraction for 90 minutes.” A to-do list says “Go to the gym.” An intention says, “Move my body in a way that feels good.”

This prompt shifts you from a reactive mindset (just handling whatever life throws at you) to a proactive mindset (deciding in advance what matters). It gives you a “win” to aim for. When you write it down, you’re 10x more likely to actually do it.

3. The Daily Affirmation (“I am…”)

This one can feel a little “woo-woo” to some, but it’s rooted in cognitive psychology. An affirmation is a simple statement that declares a positive truth about yourself in the present tense.

For example: “I am focused and capable,” “I am patient with myself,” or “I am worthy of rest.”

It works by challenging your inner critic. If your default inner voice says, “You’re lazy,” and “You’re not good enough,” writing “I am dedicated and learning” is a direct counter-punch. It creates a new, more positive mental track to play.

4. The Evening Reflection (“3 amazing things…”)

This is the bookend to your morning gratitude. At night, you’re not just grateful for what you have, you’re reflecting on what happened.

This forces you to scan your day and find specific moments of good. It trains your memory to hold onto positive events instead of letting them slide by. Even on a terrible day, you can find something: “a stranger smiled at me,” “I ate a delicious apple,” “I finished one important email.” This builds resilience.

5. The Course-Correction (“How could I have made today even better?”)

This is the most misunderstood and powerful prompt in the book. It is NOT a place to beat yourself up.

It’s not “What did I do wrong?” or “What did I fail at?”

It’s a gentle, forward-looking question. It’s a tool for a growth mindset.

• Bad answer: “I was lazy and didn’t go to the gym.”
• Good answer: “I could have gone for a 10-minute walk after lunch to feel more energy.”
• Bad answer: “I snapped at my partner.”
• Good answer: “I could have taken a deep breath before responding when I was stressed.”

See the difference? It’s not about blame. It’s about finding a small, actionable lesson. It’s a promise to your future self.

The Pros: Who is the Five Minute Journal For?

This system is brilliant for a specific type of person.

The Cons: Where Does It Fall Short?

Despite its strengths, the 5MJ is not a perfect tool for everyone.

A Pro-Tip for Trust (The “DIY” Five Minute Journal):

You don’t need to buy the official, $30 book to get the benefits. The creators themselves have shared the prompts freely.

All you need is a blank notebook.

• Page 1 (Morning): Write the 5 prompts and your answers.
• Page 1 (Evening): At the bottom, write the 2 evening prompts and your answers.
• Page 2: Repeat.

You get 100% of the psychological benefits for the price of a simple notebook.

Deep Dive: Standard Journaling (The Power of Freedom)

Now let’s look at the other side of the coin: standard journaling.

This is the classic, “blank page” approach. It’s also called free-writing, long-form journaling, or “stream-of-consciousness” writing. There are no prompts, no boxes, and no rules.

It’s just you, a pen, and a blank page.

The “How-To”: A Method With No Method

The goal of standard journaling is not to be positive. The goal is to be honest.

It’s a private space for you to meet yourself exactly as you are in that moment.

So, how do people use it?

• The “Brain Dump”: You start writing and don’t stop for 10 minutes. You write everything that’s in your head, no matter how stupid, angry, or weird. “I’m so tired today I can’t think straight, and I’m worried about that bill, and I need to remember to buy milk, and why did Sarah say that thing in the meeting…” You just dump the mental clutter onto the page so you can start your day with a clear head.
• Problem-Solving: You write about a problem you’re facing. You explore it from all angles. You ask yourself questions on the page. “I’m unhappy in my job. Why? Is it the work? No, I like the work. Is it my boss? Yes, partly. What are my options? 1. Talk to him. 2. Talk to HR. 3. Look for a new job…”
• Emotional Processing: This is its greatest strength. You can write about your feelings. “I am so angry right now. My heart is pounding. It started when…” You follow the thread of the emotion to its source.
• Creative Exploration: You can write down ideas, snippets of poems, dreams you had, or interesting conversations. It’s a sandbox for your mind.

One of the most famous methods is “Morning Pages,” created by author Julia Cameron. The rule is simple: first thing in the morning, before you do anything else, you must write three full pages, longhand, of stream-of-consciousness. It’s not “art.” It’s not even “writing.” It’s just a mental windshield wiper to clear your mind.

The Psychology: Why the Blank Page Is So Powerful

If the 5MJ is about directing your thoughts, standard journaling is about revealing them.

1. The Science of “Expressive Writing”

The pioneer in this field is Dr. James Pennebaker, a psychologist at the University of Texas. His research is fascinating.

He ran studies where he had participants write about their deepest, most traumatic experiences for 15-20 minutes a day for just 4 days. They were told to let go and explore their deepest emotions and thoughts about the event.

The results were stunning. In the long run, these participants showed improved immune system function, lower stress levels, less depression, and even better grades in school.

Why? Pennebaker believes that holding back or “inhibiting” our thoughts and feelings about big events is a form of biological stress. It takes work to keep that stuff down.

Expressive writing acts as a catharsis. It’s a release valve. When you translate that emotional chaos into a structured, written story, your brain can finally process it and file it away. You stop living in the emotion and start looking at it.

2. Cognitive Clarity

Your brain doesn’t think in neat sentences. It thinks in images, emotions, and fragments all at once.

When you force yourself to take a jumbled thought (like “I’m stressed about work”) and write it down, you have to find the words. “I am stressed because I have two deadlines, and I don’t think I have enough time, and I’m afraid of letting my team down.”

Aha! By putting it into a sentence, you just clarified the actual problem. It’s not a vague cloud of “work stress.” It’s a specific “time-management and fear-of-failure” problem. Once you’ve named it, you can start to solve it.

3. Self-Discovery

How often do you ask yourself, “How do I really feel about this?” The blank page is an invitation. You might start writing about your day and, 20 minutes later, find yourself exploring a childhood memory you hadn’t thought of in years. It connects the dots. You find out what you actually think about your life, your relationships, and your goals.

The Pros: Who is Standard Journaling For?

The Cons: Where Does It Fall Short?

Head-to-Head: The Ultimate Comparison

Let’s put the two methods side-by-side to make the choice crystal clear.

Feature	Five Minute Journal (Structure)	Standard Journaling (Freedom)
Time	Fast: 5-7 minutes, guaranteed.	Slow: 5-60+ minutes. Varies wildly.
Ease of Starting	Very Easy. Prompts are given.	Very Hard. Blank page is intimidating.
Core Goal	Gratitude & Intention. To prime your day for positivity.	Processing & Exploration. To understand your day and yourself.
Focus	Guided & Positive. You are forced to look for the good.	Open & Honest. You can write about anything (good or bad).
Flexibility	Very Low. The prompts are rigid and never change.	Very High. It’s a blank canvas for your needs.
Best For…	Building a new habit, busy people, beginners, optimists.	Processing complex emotions, writers, deep thinkers.
Biggest Risk	Repetitive & Shallow. Can feel like a chore; can’t handle deep, negative feelings.	Intimidating & Ruminating. Can be hard to start; you might get stuck in a negative loop.

How to Choose: A Simple Guide to Find Your Match

So, which one is for you? Here’s a simple decision guide.

You should start with the Five Minute Journal if…

• You are brand new to journaling and feel overwhelmed.
• You have tried journaling before and quit after a few days.
• You are very busy and “I don’t have time” is your main excuse.
• You want to build a simple, consistent daily routine.
• You struggle with anxiety or pessimism and want a tool to help you focus on the positive.

You should start with Standard Journaling if…

• You hate prompts and feel restricted by “boxes.”
• You are going through a complex or difficult emotional time (grief, breakup, life change).
• You have a lot of thoughts and feel a “pull” to write them down.
• You are a creative person or writer who wants a space for new ideas.
• You want to solve problems and understand yourself on a deeper level.

The “Third Way”: You Don’t Have to Choose

Here’s the secret that definitive guides rarely tell you: this is not a permanent, binding decision.

The best journaling practice is the one that adapts to your life. The truly “advanced” journaler knows that the tool should serve you, not the other way around.

This leads to the Hybrid Approach, which is what most long-term journalers actually do.

• The “5MJ as a Warm-Up”: Start your writing session with the 5MJ prompts. Use them to get the pen moving and to set a positive tone. Then, on the same page, flip into free-writing for 10 minutes. You get the benefit of both: a positive start and space to explore.
• The “Alternating” Method: Use the Five Minute Journal on your busy weekdays when you just need to check in. Then, on Sunday morning, you take 30 minutes with a cup of tea and your standard journal for a deep-dive free-write about your week.
• The “As-Needed” Method: Use the 5MJ as your daily baseline. But when life gets crazy, or you have a big, messy problem, you know you can grab a blank notebook and use standard journaling as your “emergency” tool for deep processing.

How to Start (and Actually Stick With It)

You’ve made your choice. You’re ready. Now, how do you make it a habit that lasts longer than a week?

If You Chose the Five Minute Journal:

1. Habit Stack: As we said, link it to something you already do. Put the journal on top of your phone before bed. When you wake up and turn off your alarm, it’s the first thing you’ll touch. Or, put it next to your toothbrush or coffee maker.
2. Don’t Overthink It: The first few gratitude entries will be obvious: “my family,” “my job,” “my home.” That’s fine. Later, get more specific: “the way my dog’s ears perk up,” “the taste of my first sip of water.”
3. Use the “2-Minute Rule”: On days you really don’t want to do it, tell yourself you only have to do it for 2 minutes. (You’ll almost always finish it, but this trick gets you started.)

If You Chose Standard Journaling:

1. Set a Timer, Not a Page Count: This is the #1 tip. “Write three pages” (like Morning Pages) is terrifying. “Write for 10 minutes” is easy. Set a timer and just keep the pen moving until it goes off. If you get stuck, literally write “I don’t know what to write” over and over until a new thought appears. It will.
2. Use Prompts When You’re Stuck: A blank page is scary. A prompted blank page is an invitation. You don’t need a guided journal, you just need a good question.
3. Give Yourself Permission to Be “Bad”: This is not for an audience. This is for you. No one will ever read it. Give yourself permission to have bad handwriting, to use a “bad” notebook, to have spelling mistakes, and to write boring, whiny, or angry sentences. It’s a “first draft” of your thoughts.

Bonus: 20 Prompts for Your Standard Journal

If you’re stuck on a blank page, just pick one of these and go.

1. What is one thing that’s draining my energy right now?
2. What is one thing that’s giving me energy right now?
3. If I could have a conversation with my 10-year-old self, what would I say?
4. If my 90-year-old self could give me advice, what would they say?
5. What’s a “small win” from today or this week that I haven’t celebrated?
6. Describe a time I felt truly myself. Where was I? Who was I with?
7. What am I afraid of right now? What’s the worst that could happen? How would I handle it?
8. Write out a “perfect” day. From the moment you wake up to the moment you sleep. Be specific.
9. What’s a conversation I’m avoiding? What do I wish I could say?
10. If I had an extra two hours this week, what would I love to do with them?
11. What’s a mistake I made recently, and what did I learn from it?
12. “Right now, I am feeling…” (and just keep writing).
13. What’s one thing I can do today to be kinder to my future self?
14. What’s a belief I hold that might not be true?
15. “I feel most at peace when…”
16. “I feel most stressed when…”
17. What’s one thing I’ve been comparing myself to others about?
18. “I’m letting go of…”
19. “I’m inviting in…”
20. What’s one question I don’t have the answer to right now, and how does that feel?

The Final Verdict: The Best Journal is the One You Use

We’ve covered it all: the speed of the Five Minute Journal versus the depth of standard journaling. The power of positive priming versus the release of expressive writing.

The final, simple truth is this: There is no “better” method. There is only what is better for you, right now.

A journal is a tool. That’s it. It’s not a test. You don’t get a grade. You can’t fail at it.

If your journal practice starts to feel like a “toxic” chore (like the 5MJ on a bad day) or an overwhelming burden (like the blank page when you’re tired), then it’s not working. Don’t be afraid to switch.

• Ditch the 5MJ for a week and just “brain dump” in a blank notebook.
• Ditch the blank notebook and try the 5MJ prompts to get your habit back on track.

Your needs will change. Your life will change. Your journal should change with you.

The real goal is not to “be a journaler.” The goal is to be a person who is a little more self-aware, a little more intentional, a little more resilient, and a little more at peace than you were yesterday.

So pick one. Grab a $1 notebook or a $30 guided journal. It doesn’t matter.

Just start. Write one sentence. Then another. Your future self will thank you for it.

Further Reading & Authoritative Resources

For those who want to go even deeper, here are the foundational resources and respected voices on these topics:

1. Intelligent Change: The official creators of the Five Minute Journal. Their blog explores the science of gratitude, habit-formation, and positive psychology.
2. Dr. James W. Pennebaker: The father of “expressive writing.” His website and his book, Opening Up by Writing It Down, are the definitive academic sources on how writing heals.
3. Julia Cameron: The creator of “Morning Pages.” Her book, The Artist’s Way, is a classic for creatives looking to unblock themselves with stream-of-consciousness writing.
4. Psychology Today: A great resource with countless articles from therapists and psychologists on the different cognitive benefits of journaling for anxiety, depression, and more.
5. Tim Ferriss: While he didn’t invent it, Tim Ferriss popularized the Five Minute Journal on his podcast. His blog, The Tim Ferriss Show, is a deep archive of interviews on routines and habits.